Trope Tuesday: The Love Triangle — 8 Favorite Picks

Quick definition:

When one heart just isn’t enough. The Love Triangle thrives on tension—two potential loves, both real, both flawed, pulling our protagonist in opposite directions. It’s longing, loyalty, and timing at war.

Why we love it:

Because chaos is romantic. The best triangles aren’t about indecision—they’re about identity. They show how love reflects who we are (and who we could be). We stay for the yearning, the angst, and that one stolen look that ruins everything.

Our favorites (with vibes):

Shatter Me — Tahereh Mafi

Vibes: dystopian drama, soft boy vs. chaos boy, power awakening

Why we love it: Juliette’s love life mirrors her growth—from afraid and controlled to fierce and free. Every choice changes who she becomes.

One True Loves — Taylor Jenkins Reid

Vibes: second chances, quiet heartbreak, love after loss

Why we love it: A grounded triangle about timing and identity—what happens when your heart belongs to two different versions of yourself.

New Moon — Stephenie Meyer

Vibes: nostalgia, longing, daylight vs. darkness

Why we love it: The blueprint of YA triangles. Bella’s torn between stability and danger, and the ache is half the point.

Clockwork Angel — Cassandra Clare

Vibes: Victorian fantasy, loyalty, sacrifice, found family

Why we love it: The rare triangle where every side hurts. Will and Jem both love deeply, and Tessa’s choice breaks us in the best way.

The Elite — Kiera Cass

Vibes: royal reality TV, gowns, pressure, public heartbreak

Why we love it: The triangle isn’t just emotional—it’s political. Choosing love means choosing your future, in front of everyone.

Every Summer After — Carley Fortune

Vibes: lakeside nostalgia, reunion romance, slow-burn regret

Why we love it: A summer-saturated ache about past love and present choices. The emotional realism hits hard.

The Vampire Diaries: The Awakening — L.J. Smith

Vibes: supernatural angst, danger vs. devotion, 2000s nostalgia

Why we love it: The triangle that launched a thousand fan wars. Elena, Damon, and Stefan—equal parts obsession and fate.

The Hunger Games — Suzanne Collins

Vibes: survival, rebellion, love under fire

Why we love it: Katniss’s triangle isn’t about romance—it’s about ideology. Peeta or Gale? Comfort or conviction? Her heart becomes a mirror for revolution.

---

Join the conversation:

Team loyal or team chaos? Drop a ❤️‍🔥 or 💔 in the comments—we’ll reply with a personalized rec (and judgment-free triangle talk).

Listen & follow along:

Prefer to listen? We talk tropes every week—new episode Oct 9th: We Are All Guilty Here. Full show notes drop on episode day—check the blog so you don’t miss it.

---

Mini FAQ:

Does a Love Triangle always mean “two people fighting over one”?

Usually—but sometimes it’s a triangle of timing or fate. The conflict isn’t just who you love, but when and why.

Why do readers get so divided?

Because each side represents a different version of the main character’s life. It’s never just Team A or B—it’s Team “Who am I becoming?”

Why does this trope flop sometimes?

When one love interest feels like filler, or the choice doesn’t cost anything. We need tension, growth, and stakes that cut.

Where should I start from this list?

Supernatural drama & nostalgia: The Vampire Diaries

Fantasy heartbreak: Clockwork Angel

Real-world ache: One True Loves

Summer second chances: Every Summer After

Classic dystopian divide: The Hunger Games

Chaotic romantasy tension: Shatter Me