My Husband’s Wife by Alice Feeney — Genre’d Podcast
- genredpodcast
- 1 day ago
- 5 min read
This week on Genre’d, we’re talking My Husband’s Wife by Alice Feeney, a psychological thriller that asks: what if you went out for a run, came home 30 minutes later, and someone else was living your life, wearing your face, and insisting you were the problem.
But first, we have some things to say.
Katy is hot off a happy hour and immediately resurrects a deeply specific fear rooted in early-2000s cinema. This leads to a passionate defense of forgotten MTV original movies, a reminder that Carmen: A Hip Hopera was a cultural moment, and the realization that a shocking number of people do not know about Brokedown Palace and should maybe educate themselves.
Elyse brings us into book-to-screen discourse, including why fantasy adaptations keep missing the mark, why author control actually matters, and why “prestige TV or nothing” might be the correct stance going forward.
💥 Spoiler warning: The first ~20 minutes are spoiler-free (synopsis, characters, vibes, who should read). Full spoilers after that.
About My Husband’s Wife
small town. big secrets.
When a woman begins a new life with her husband in a remote English coastal village, the past refuses to stay buried. After going out for a routine run, she returns home to find another woman inside her house claiming to be her.
What follows is a psychological thriller built on shifting timelines, unreliable narrators, and the unsettling question of how well anyone really knows the people closest to them.
This is a story about marriage, memory, guilt, and how quickly reality can unravel when everyone insists they are telling the truth.
We have some things to say
🎬 MTV original movies deserve respect: Carmen: A Hip Hopera, Wuthering Heights (yes, the MTV version), and Brokedown Palace are cultural artifacts, and we will not be taking questions at this time.
📺 Fantasy adaptations are high-risk, high-reward: we talk Brandon Sanderson, author control, and why fantasy only works on screen when the people who built the world are actually allowed to protect it.
📚 Thriller expectations vs reality: when twists feel earned versus when they feel like information was simply withheld.
What we cover in this episode
Genre and vibes
Psychological thriller with heavy unreliable narrator energy
Small-town coastal setting where no one seems to know anyone
British crime drama vibes, but stranger and more disorienting
Tropes and story DNA
Unreliable narrators across multiple POVs
Dual timelines that eventually collideIdentity confusion and doppelgänger horror
Marriage secrets and long-buried guilt
Characters to watch
Eden Fox: an artist trying to start over, slowly losing her grip on reality
Harrison Wolf: the husband, the CEO, and the walking red flag
Birdie: a London detective with a terminal diagnosis and unfinished business
Luke Carter: the small-town cop doing his best in a one-horse police station
Gabriella: the daughter at the emotional center of everything
What it’s giving
British crime drama energy
A seaside town where no one knows what anyone looks like
A mystery that feels one step ahead and one step unhinged
Would our mother read this
Yes. Surprisingly, yes.
One line plots
Katy:
In a town where no one seems to know what anyone looks like, what happened in the past decade, or what is currently going on, a woman learns her death date and sets off a series of unfortunate and deeply confusing events.
Elyse:
A woman meets her doppelgänger and probably begins to lose her mind, kicking off a chaotic whodunit featuring a feckless cop, a postcard-perfect seaside town, and far too many points of view insisting they are right.
⚠️ Spoilers ahead ⚠️
Okay. Spoiler alarm. Spoiler, spoiler.
The big structure problem
This book relies heavily on characters knowing each other and simply not saying it. The result is a twist that feels less like a reveal and more like being told information that realistically would have come up much earlier.
As readers, we are not discovering the truth alongside the characters. We are waiting to be informed.
That distinction mattered a lot to both of us.
The plan (which is… bananas)
Once the timelines converge, we learn that multiple characters have been quietly orchestrating an elaborate plan to discredit and remove Eden.
This includes:
Lock changes executed at lightning speed
Identity swapping
Strategic withholding of basic information
A cliffside “backup plan” that relies on everything going exactly right
It is ambitious. It is convoluted. It is extremely dependent on no one asking follow-up questions.
The final twist and why we were not seated
The ultimate reveal of who actually killed Eden comes from a character we were not emotionally invested in, which made the ending feel abrupt rather than shocking.
The twist itself is not bad. The emotional groundwork just was not there.
We did not feel tricked in a fun way. We felt informed very late.
What we wish we had more of
Clearer emotional stakes between the major players
Fewer twists that rely on coincidence and confusion
More earned reveals instead of withheld information
A mystery that unfolds with the reader, not after them
Final ratings
⭐️⭐️⭐️½ Katy: 3.5 stars. Entertaining and twisty, but the unreliable narrator mechanics crossed into frustration rather than intrigue.
⭐️⭐️⭐️ Elyse: 3 stars. Fun and readable, but the twists did not fully land. This might work better as a TV show.
Mentions
Brokedown Palace
Carmen: A Hip Hopera
Wuthering Heights (MTV original movie)
His & Hers by Alice Feeney
British crime drama adaptations
What’s next on Genre’d
Next up, we are switching gears into full sports romance chaos with Catcher If You Can by Tessa Bailey, which promises to be our smuttiest read yet.
Join the conversation
Do you like thrillers where the confusion is part of the experience, or do you need twists to feel earned in real time?
Are unreliable narrators fun for you, or do they make you feel like you missed a chapter?
Tag us, DM us, and tell us where you landed.
Listen and follow along
👉 Listen on Spotify | Apple Podcasts | YouTube
👉 Explore more episodes of Genre’d Podcast
👉 Follow us on Instagram & TikTok @genredpodcast
⭐ If you like the show, please rate, review, and subscribe.
📚 Remember: no genre shaming unless it’s funny.
Fast facts
Book: My Husband’s Wife
Author: Alice Feeney
Genre: Psychological thriller
Episode format: spoiler-free first ~20 minutes, then full spoilers
Our rating: 3–3.5 stars
Mini FAQ
Is this episode spoiler-free?
The first ~20 minutes are spoiler-free. After that, we get into full spoilers and the ending.
Is My Husband’s Wife scary?
No. It is psychological and unsettling, but not horror-level scary.
Who should read this book?
Readers who like unreliable narrators, small-town thrillers, and twist-heavy plots that play with perception.
Does the audiobook add anything?
Yes. The duet narration and British accents help differentiate POVs and add atmosphere.
Would Genre’d recommend it?
With caveats. It is entertaining, but some twists feel more withheld than earned.
Is this better as a TV adaptation?
Honestly, yes. We think this story might land better on screen.
Comments